[Not the reaction he expected to get at all. Suddenly, Hal is getting this sinking feeling, like there's something very wrong here. His head is starting to hurt]

Sure. We have dinner together every night, don't we? [That's not right, either. Nothing about this is right. He gets the feeling that there's something he's forgetting but he can't place it]

Hey, Carol. Humor me for a second. How long have we been together?